So You Want To Be A Mentat
Mentats are described in Frank Herbert's Dune as "a class of Imperial citizens trained for supreme accomplishments in logic - Human Computers." They can survey astonishing quantities of information and perform analytical feats - all without computers.

(Thufir Hawat, Mentat to the Atreides)
Here is a basic outline of the Mentat "feature list:"
- Extraordinary capacity for conscious information acquisition
- Rapid computation skills
- Near total recall
- Unshakable concentration
- Calculates human and social costs without emotion
- Wide-ranging analytical talents (social, financial, military)
Are there any tools or techniques available that could help? Let's take a look at these items one-by-one.
1. Extraordinary capacity for conscious information acquisition
There are a variety of different methods that supposedly increase your ability to take in information. Early work by psychologists was done using the tachistoscope, a machine that flashes words before the user at a set rate. Additional work was done in trying to increase the size of the reader's field of focus. The Evelyn Wood Speed Reading method was well-known in the 1960's. (She coined the term "speed reading."
A variety of methods have been evolved to help people acquire different kinds of information. Hermann Ebbinghaus introduced the idea of a "learning curve" in the late 19th century. The would-be Mentat would be able to surmount a steep learning curve effortlessly.
Individuals have shown remarkable results, so there is some real potential here. However, no study I'm aware of has distinguished between people who had a remarkable natural capacity, and those who were average and became extraordinary.
2. Rapid computation skills
There are a variety of different tricks for performing math in your head; some of these methods work well enough to encourage the idea that a person could have Mentat-level calculation skills.
One typical example that I recall reading about in the 1960's was the Trachtenberg speed system. Trachtenberg was a Holocaust survivor who created the system himself in a Nazi concentration camp. His method consists of a number of different tricks to make particular mathematical operations easier to perform without pencil and paper.
My personal interest in speed calculation waned when I noticed that a) science and math teachers tended to make the answers "come out even", b) slide rules worked well enough when only 2-3 significant figures were required and (the death knell) c) hand-held calculators were right around the corner.
Heinlein fans will recall the calculation method mastered by the "man who was too lazy to fail" in his Lazarus Long collection Time Enough for Love. By memorizing a table of logarithms, he was able to perform remarkable feats of multiplication and division by simple addition and subtraction.
3. Near total recall
As one of those people with a good memory, I naturally wanted a better one. A variety of books came out starting in the 1960's on improving memory. Most of these books use some sort of a system to make sure you are really paying attention by using some sort of imagery or other mnemonic device.
I was really impressed when Hannibal Lecter, Thomas Harris' greatest literary creation, is shown to use a memory palace, also called the Method of Loci. The idea is at least several millennia old.
The traditional progenitor of this system was Simonides of Crete. He was attending a dinner with a large number of guests; when he stepped outside, the roof chanced to collapse. He was able to identify all of the mangled remains by going remembering their positions relative to each other.
The basic idea is that you remember a place, or a journey, well enough to visualize it. Then, you take the first of the facts to be memorized, and "walk" to the first location. Then you create a fantastic image that helps you remember the details of the fact. Off you go to the second location, where you create another image. By mentally "retracing your steps" and examining each image, you can recall the facts.
Mnemonics is another favorite; it takes time and concentration to create a good mnemonic, which reveals it as another trick to get you pay careful attention. It also puts facts into an ordered set, which provides additional information. For example, all physics and astronomy students remember the spectral types of stars in order by temperature - OBAFGKMRNS - using the mnemonic "oh, be a fine girl, kiss me right now, sweetie."
Putting the facts in the form of a rhyme or song also helps; back in the day, I could reel off all 180 four line stanzas (plus lengthy introductory mantras) of my favorite meditation text from memory with no problem. I can remember all the words to "Baby Got Back" by Sir Mixalot using the same method.
4. Unshakable concentration
This brings us to concentration; there is no substitute. My daughter claims that she is at her learning peak when she is "multi-tasking," which is what she calls it when she is a) watching "America's Top Model," b) instant messaging friends on a laptop, c) listening to music and d) studying - all at the same time. As soon as her grades start to slip, I'll get my chance to defend the virtues of concentrating on one thing at a time.
Methods of forcing human beings to concentrate are as old as humanity. Most religions have some sort of tradition of improving concentration. Modern meditation teachers detach the methods from the religion for you.
As a sidebar on concentration, I would add that Mentats are known to use a substance, sapho juice, to "amplify mental powers." The idea that there is a materialist method (that is, some sort of pill) for improving one's concentration and mental powers is undergoing a real renaissance now.
5. Calculates human and social costs without emotion
It is very difficult to calculate and evaluate without emotion. Warren Buffett can do it, and most financial gurus believe that it is one of the keys to his success.
Mentats were famed for using Zen-like states of concentration - the Mentat semitrance - to enter new heights of one-pointed meditation on their data.
There are software products available that teach stock trading without emotion; the StockReflex simulator claims to help people learn to trade without being unduly influenced by fear and greed.
6. Wide-ranging analytical talents (social, financial, military)
This is probably the most difficult area for those who would like to become a Mentat. Although business schools teach that once you have learned the necessary principles, you can analyze any business situation, I've found it to be more difficult. Unless you know the details, you can't really master any situation well enough to perform a successful analysis.

(Piter de Vries, Mentat to the Harkonnens)
You might as well begin your Mentat training by carefully studying and memorizing all of the technology of Dune. Thanks to Adi for suggesting this topic.
Scroll down for more stories in the same category. (Story submitted 5/13/2008)
Follow this kind of news @Technovelgy.
| Email | RSS | Blog It | Stumble | del.icio.us | Digg | Reddit |
Would
you like to contribute a story tip?
It's easy:
Get the URL of the story, and the related sf author, and add
it here.
Comment/Join discussion ( 2 )
Related News Stories -
("
Culture
")
Is It Time To Forbid Human Driving?
'Heavy penalties... were to be applied to any one found driving manually-controlled machines.' - Bernard Brown, 1934.
Indonesian Clans Battle
'The observation vehicle was of that peculiar variety used in conveying a large number of people across rough terrain.' - Jack Vance (1952)
Liuzhi Process Now In Use In China
'He was in a high-ceilinged windowless cell with walls of glittering white porcelain.' - George Orwell, 1984.
Animated Tumblebugs On Astounding Cover!
'Gaines and Harvey mounted tumblebugs, and kept abreast of the Cadet Captain...'
Technovelgy (that's tech-novel-gee!)
is devoted to the creative science inventions and ideas of sf authors. Look for
the Invention Category that interests
you, the Glossary, the Invention
Timeline, or see what's New.
|
Science Fiction
Timeline
1600-1899
1900-1939
1940's 1950's
1960's 1970's
1980's 1990's
2000's 2010's
Current News
Golf Ball Test Robot Wears Them Out
"The robot solemnly hit a ball against the wall, picked it up and teed it, hit it again, over and again...'
Boring Company Vegas Loop Like Asimov Said
'There was a wall ahead... It was riddled with holes that were the mouths of tunnels.'
Rigid Metallic Clothing From Science Fiction To You
'...support the interior human structure against Jupiter’s pull.'
Is The Seattle Ultrasonics C-200 A Heinlein Vibroblade?
'It ain't a vibroblade. It's steel. Messy.'
Roborock Saros Z70 Is A Robot Vacuum With An Arm
'Anything larger than a BB shot it picked up and placed in a tray...'
A Beautiful Visualization Of Compact Food
'The German chemists have discovered how to supply the needed elements in compact, undiluted form...'
Bone-Building Drug Evenity Approved
'Compounds devised by the biochemists for the rapid building of bone...'
Secret Kill Switch Found In Yutong Buses
'The car faltered as the external command came to brake...'
Inmotion Electric Unicycle In Combat
'It is about the size and shape of a kitchen stool, gyro-stabilized...'
Grok Scores Best In Psychological Tests
'Try to find out how he ticks...'
PaXini Supersensitive Robot Fingers
'My fingers are not that sensitive...'
Congress Considers Automatic Emergency Braking, One Hundred Years Too Late
'The greatest problem of all was the elimination of the human element of braking together with its inevitable time lag.'
The Desert Ship Sailed In Imagination
'Across the ancient sea floor a dozen tall, blue-sailed Martian sand ships floated, like blue smoke.'
The Zapata Air Scooter Would Be Great In A Science Fiction Story
'Betty's slapdash style.'
Thermostabilized Wet Meat Product (NASA Prototype)
There are no orbiting Michelin stars. Yet.
Could Crystal Batteries Generate Power For Centuries?
'Power could be compressed thus into an inch-square cube of what looked like blue-white ice'
More SF in the News Stories
More Beyond Technovelgy science news stories
|